Karen Kilgariff's Marriages: Unveiling Her Past Relationships

Weldon Kozey 26 May 2025

Ever wondered about the personal life of your favorite comedian and podcast host? Karen Kilgariff's journey through love and marriage is as captivating as her true crime tales, marked by both joy and heartbreak.

Karen Kilgariff, the American writer, comedian, singer, actress, television producer, and podcast host, best known for co-hosting "My Favorite Murder," has carved a significant niche in the entertainment industry. Born on May 11, 1970, in Petaluma, California, her career has been marked by diverse roles and collaborations, leading to widespread recognition and a dedicated following. However, beyond her professional achievements, her personal life, particularly her marital history, has piqued the curiosity of many. The question of who was Karen Kilgariff married to? is a common one, reflecting the public's interest in the individuals who have shared her life.

Full Name	Karen Kilgariff
Birth Date	May 11, 1970
Birth Place	Petaluma, California, USA
Age	54 years old (as of 2024)
Nationality	American
Occupation	Writer, Comedian, Singer, Actress, Television Producer, Podcast Host
Known For	Co-hosting "My Favorite Murder" podcast
Net Worth (approx.)	$20 Million (as of recent estimates)
Relationship Status	Currently Single
Past Marriages	Michael Charles Edward Hobert, Nick Thune, Peter Thompson (reportedly)
Hobbies & Interests	True Crime, Comedy, Mental Health Advocacy
Additional Information	Has been open about her past struggles with substance abuse and mental health.
Reference Link	My Favorite Murder Official Website

Delving into her marital history, it's revealed that Karen Kilgariff has been married more than once. One confirmed marriage was to Michael Charles Edward Hobert, an actor and writer. They exchanged vows in 2001, marking the beginning of a union that would last for over a decade. Their relationship, like many, faced its challenges, ultimately leading to a divorce in 2014. This period was undoubtedly significant in Kilgariff's life, influencing both her personal and professional trajectory.

Another notable chapter in her romantic life involves Nick Thune, an acclaimed comedian, actor, and writer. Kilgariff and Thune were married from 2005 to 2012. Their time together was characterized by navigating the complexities of life, love, and shared careers in the entertainment industry. This relationship, too, played a crucial role in shaping her perspective and experiences.

Interestingly, there are also reports and mentions in various sources about a marriage to Peters Thompson. Some accounts indicate that Peters Thompson and Karen Kilgariff were divorced after a marriage of 12 years. Court records from Los Angeles County show a "dissolution w/o minor children (general jurisdiction)" lawsuit filed against Kilgariff by Thompson, represented by legal counsel. However, details surrounding this relationship are less publicly available compared to her marriages with Hobert and Thune.

Born under the zodiac sign of Taurus, Karen Kilgariff exhibits traits often associated with this sign, such as a strong will, practicality, and an appreciation for the finer things in life. However, her journey has not been without its challenges. Kilgariff has been open about her past struggles with the abuse of amphetamines and diet pills, showcasing her resilience and commitment to personal growth. This transparency has made her a relatable figure to many, especially those who have faced similar challenges.

Her career began long before the immense success of "My Favorite Murder." Kilgariff has appeared on multiple cooking channel shows, demonstrating her versatility and passion for culinary arts. She has also contributed her writing talents to publications like Elle and Food Network Online, further solidifying her presence in the media landscape. Additionally, she was twice a guest narrator on Comedy Central's "Drunk History," a testament to her comedic timing and storytelling abilities.

The podcast "My Favorite Murder," which she co-hosts with Georgia Hardstark, has been a game-changer in the true crime podcasting world. Since its inception in 2016, the podcast has garnered a massive following, consistently ranking as one of iTunes' top-rated comedy podcasts. The show's success can be attributed to the hosts' engaging personalities, their thoughtful approach to discussing sensitive topics, and their ability to create a sense of community among listeners. The podcast's popularity has also spawned a dedicated fan base known as "Murderinos," who actively participate in online forums, meetups, and charitable initiatives.

Beyond her work in entertainment, Karen Kilgariff is also known for her advocacy for mental health awareness. Her openness about her own struggles has inspired many to seek help and support. She often uses her platform to discuss mental health issues, share resources, and encourage conversations around these important topics. Her advocacy work has made her a role model for those who admire her honesty and vulnerability.

Despite her professional success and public persona, Karen Kilgariff maintains a relatively private personal life. She currently resides in Studio City, California, with her two dogs, George and Frank. Her love for her pets is evident in her social media posts and anecdotes shared on her podcast. Her home serves as a sanctuary where she can unwind, recharge, and focus on her creative pursuits.

Her mother, Patricia Kilgariff (née Knight), passed away on January 9, 2016, after a 12-year battle with early-onset Alzheimer's disease. Patricia was a nurse specializing in mental health, having graduated from Providence Nursing School of Oakland in 1962. The loss of her mother was a profound experience for Karen, further shaping her perspective on life, family, and the importance of cherishing relationships.

In recent years, Karen Kilgariff has demonstrated a noticeable shift in her personal life. As one listener noted in a post, she has gone through a "painful and beautiful growth process" where she has worked through an isolation pattern. Nowadays, her anecdotes almost always involve being around other people, reflecting a newfound emphasis on connection and community. This transformation speaks to her commitment to self-improvement and her willingness to embrace new experiences.

Karen Kilgariff's journey is a testament to her resilience, talent, and dedication. From her early career beginnings to her current status as a leading figure in the podcasting world, she has consistently demonstrated her ability to adapt, evolve, and connect with audiences. Her marital history, while a subject of public interest, is just one facet of her multifaceted life. Ultimately, she is defined by her work, her advocacy, and her unwavering commitment to making a positive impact on the world.

Her multifaceted career includes not only podcasting but also writing for television shows, performing stand-up comedy, and even singing. She has lent her voice to various projects, showcasing her versatility as an entertainer. Her comedic timing and wit have made her a sought-after performer, and her ability to connect with audiences on a personal level has contributed to her enduring success.

Karen Kilgariff's impact extends beyond the entertainment industry. She is a role model for aspiring comedians, writers, and podcasters, demonstrating that success is achievable through hard work, dedication, and a willingness to be authentic. Her story is an inspiration to many, showing that it is possible to overcome challenges, pursue one's passions, and make a meaningful difference in the world.

The success of "My Favorite Murder" has also led to numerous spin-off projects, including live shows, merchandise, and even a book. These ventures have further solidified Kilgariff's position as a leading figure in the true crime genre and have allowed her to connect with her fans in new and exciting ways. The podcast's popularity has also sparked a broader interest in true crime storytelling, leading to the emergence of numerous similar podcasts and documentaries.

Karen Kilgariff's approach to true crime is unique in that she combines humor with sensitivity. While she and Georgia Hardstark often inject comedic elements into their discussions, they also treat the victims and their families with respect and compassion. This balance has made their podcast appealing to a wide range of listeners, including those who are typically turned off by the often-sensationalized nature of true crime media.

Her involvement in various charitable initiatives further highlights her commitment to giving back to the community. She has supported organizations that focus on mental health, addiction recovery, and violence prevention. Her philanthropic efforts reflect her values and her desire to make a positive impact on the lives of others.

Karen Kilgariff's influence extends beyond her professional accomplishments. She has become a cultural icon, representing a new generation of female comedians and entertainers who are unafraid to be themselves, challenge conventions, and speak their minds. Her honesty, wit, and compassion have made her a beloved figure among her fans, who admire her for her authenticity and her unwavering commitment to her values.

As she continues to evolve and explore new creative avenues, Karen Kilgariff remains a force to be reckoned with in the entertainment industry. Her talent, her passion, and her dedication to her craft ensure that she will continue to inspire and entertain audiences for years to come. Her journey is a testament to the power of resilience, authenticity, and the importance of finding one's voice.

The stories shared on "My Favorite Murder" often resonate deeply with listeners, prompting conversations about safety, justice, and the human condition. Kilgariff and Hardstark's ability to create a safe and supportive space for these discussions has contributed to the podcast's widespread appeal and its positive impact on the true crime community.

Karen Kilgariff's career is a shining example of how one can achieve success by pursuing their passions and staying true to themselves. Her journey is a testament to the power of hard work, dedication, and the importance of embracing one's unique talents and perspectives. Her story serves as an inspiration to aspiring entertainers and anyone who dreams of making a difference in the world.

In conclusion, while the question of who was Karen Kilgariff married to? is a frequent inquiry, it's essential to recognize that her marital history is just one aspect of her complex and fascinating life. She is a talented writer, comedian, and podcaster who has made a significant impact on the entertainment industry and beyond. Her journey is a testament to her resilience, her authenticity, and her unwavering commitment to her values.